Genesis · chapter 44 of 50
Updated on
Genesis 44 tells how Joseph has his silver cup hidden in Benjamin's sack and then sends his steward after the brothers. The cup is found in Benjamin's sack, and all return to Egypt. Judah tells Joseph of Jacob's grief and offers to stay as a slave in place of Benjamin, so that the boy may go home to his father.
Genesis 43 ended with a joyful meal. Genesis 44 holds Joseph's last and hardest test of his brothers. What is at stake is whether Jacob's sons will treat Benjamin the way they treated Joseph. Judah's speech is one of the longest and most moving in Genesis, and shows the transformation of a man.
Joseph orders his steward to fill his brothers' sacks with as much grain as they can carry, put each man's money in his sack and put his silver cup in the sack of the youngest. At dawn the brothers set out. When they have scarcely left the city, Joseph sends the steward after them to accuse them of stealing the cup from which Joseph drinks and divines. They defend themselves: they brought back the money found in their sacks, so why would they steal silver or gold? They say that whoever has it should die, and the rest will be slaves. The steward agrees with a variation: only the one who has it will be a slave.
They search the sacks from the oldest to the youngest, and the cup is found in Benjamin's. The brothers tear their clothes, load their donkeys and return to the city. They come before Joseph and fall to the ground. Judah speaks for them all. He offers no defense, but says God has found out their guilt.
Joseph says only Benjamin will remain as a slave, and the others may go in peace. Then Judah steps forward and tells him the whole story in detail: the aged father, the brother who is dead, the youngest son who is all that is left of his mother. If Benjamin does not return, Jacob will die of grief. Judah had pledged himself as a guarantor. So he begs to be allowed to stay as a slave in place of the boy, and for the boy to go up with his brothers, because he cannot bear to see the misery that would come on his father.
References follow ESV book names and verse numbers. Read each verse in your Bible before the explanation.
Judah says that God has found out the guilt of his servants. He does not protest innocence in this particular accusation, but acknowledges an older guilt and owns it before God. It is an important step of repentance.
Judah explains that Jacob's life is bound up with the boy's life, and that if he does not return, his father will die of grief. With these words Judah shows that he understands what he once did to his father by selling Joseph.
Judah asks to stay as a slave in place of the boy and for him to go up with his brothers. It is a voluntary substitution: the brother who sold Joseph now gives up his freedom for another son of Rachel. Christian readers see in it an echo of Christ.
Judah ends by saying he cannot go back to his father without the boy, for he could not bear to see the misery that would come on Jacob. His care for his father is the final proof that he is no longer the man who sold Joseph.
6 questions with answers and references, ready for Sunday school, small group or a Bible quiz night.
Answer: In the sack of Benjamin, the youngest. — Genesis 44:2
Answer: That whoever had the cup should die and the rest would be slaves. — Genesis 44:9
Answer: They tore their clothes, loaded their donkeys and returned to the city. — Genesis 44:13
Answer: That God had found out the guilt of his servants. — Genesis 44:16
Answer: To stay as a slave in place of Benjamin and let the boy go back with his brothers. — Genesis 44:33
Answer: Because he could not bear to see the misery that would come on his father. — Genesis 44:34
Genesis 44 shows the fruit of repentance: Judah, who sold a brother, now gives his freedom for another. In a small group, the chapter invites us to ask whether our repentance reaches the point of changing our actions, and whether we are willing to pay a price for those who depend on us.
Christians see in Judah a shadow of Christ, who gave himself in place of others. That reading must be made carefully, because Judah is a flawed man. Ask whom you need to protect with your sacrifice, and how Christ's work on the cross moves you to do it.
Genesis 44 ends with Judah's plea, with no answer from Joseph yet. In Genesis 45, Joseph will no longer be able to restrain himself and will make himself known to his brothers, and the story reaches its most moving moment.
The text does not give the motive explicitly. The test of the cup shows whether the brothers would abandon Benjamin, as they did Joseph, and gives Judah the chance to reveal himself. His answer shows they have changed.
The steward says Joseph used it for divination, but the text does not claim Joseph practiced divination. It was probably part of the front Joseph kept up before his brothers to keep his identity hidden.
Judah offers himself as a substitute for the youngest son, to free him and save his father. Christians see there a distant echo of Jesus, a descendant of Judah, who gave his life in place of others. It is a reading by type, not a direct statement of the text.