Why did Ishmael kill Gedaliah?
The text mentions that Baalis, king of Ammon, had sent him (40:14), and that Ishmael was of royal descent. He probably wanted to remove the man Babylon had put in power. The passage gives no further motives.
Jeremiah · chapter 41 of 52
Jeremiah 41: Summary, Key Verses and Study Questions
Updated on
What happens in Jeremiah 41?
Jeremiah 41 narrates the murder of Gedaliah at Mizpah by Ishmael son of Nethaniah, in the seventh month. Ishmael also kills the Babylonian soldiers and seventy pilgrims from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria, and takes captives toward Ammon. Johanan pursues him and rescues the captives at Gibeon, but the group, afraid of Babylon, stops near Bethlehem to flee to Egypt.
This chapter fulfills the fear the previous one left open. Gedaliah had asked for trust and work in the land, but the violence of a man with political ambitions undoes that opportunity. The tragedy of Mizpah explains why those left in Judah felt in danger and decided to seek refuge in Egypt.
Jeremiah 41 summary
In the seventh month Ishmael son of Nethaniah, of the royal family, comes with ten men to Mizpah, where Gedaliah receives them and they eat together. Ishmael and the ten rise up and strike Gedaliah down with the sword, and kill all the Jews who were with him and the Chaldean soldiers who were at Mizpah.
The next day, before anyone knew, eighty men arrive from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria, with beards shaved, clothes torn and bodies gashed, bringing offerings and incense for the house of the Lord. Ishmael goes out to meet them, weeping, and invites them to come to Gedaliah. Once they are inside the city, he kills them and throws them into a cistern, except for ten who offer him treasures hidden in the field. The rest he throws into the large cistern that King Asa had made. Then Ishmael takes captive the rest of the people of Mizpah, including the king's daughters, and sets out for the Ammonites.
Johanan son of Kareah and the commanders hear what Ishmael has done and go out to fight him. They find him by the great pool at Gibeon. The captives are glad to see Johanan and turn to him. Ishmael escapes with eight men to the Ammonites. Johanan gathers those he rescued, and, afraid of the Chaldeans because Ishmael killed Gedaliah, the governor appointed by Babylon, he stops at Geruth Chimham near Bethlehem, intending to go to Egypt.
Chapter outline
- vv. 1-3: Ishmael murders Gedaliah and those with him at Mizpah.
- vv. 4-10: He kills pilgrims from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria and takes captives.
- vv. 11-15: Johanan pursues him and rescues the captives at Gibeon.
- vv. 16-18: The group stops near Bethlehem, afraid of Babylon, to flee to Egypt.
Key verses in Jeremiah 41
References follow ESV book names and verse numbers. Read each verse in your Bible before the explanation.
Jeremiah 41:2
Ishmael rises with ten men and kills Gedaliah, whom Babylon had put over the land. He breaks the shared meal, a symbol of trust, and strikes down the last hope of a stable life for those who remained.
Jeremiah 41:5-6
The pilgrims from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria come in mourning, with offerings for the house of the Lord, and Ishmael goes out to meet them weeping. The deceit increases the horror: he uses the grief of others as a trap to murder them.
Jeremiah 41:15
Ishmael escapes Johanan with eight men, and the captives are free. The rescue is real, but it settles nothing: the murderer is still alive and the land is again an unsafe place.
Jeremiah 41:17-18
The group stops near Bethlehem to flee to Egypt out of fear of the Chaldeans. God had already said how to live under Babylon, but the people again decide out of fear and not out of obedience.
Main themes
- Betrayal and violence
- Deceit dressed as religion
- Fear that decides badly
- Broken hope
People and places
- Ishmael son of Nethaniah
- Gedaliah
- Johanan son of Kareah
- The pilgrims from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria
- The Chaldeans
- Mizpah
- Gibeon
- Bethlehem
Jeremiah 41 study questions and answers
6 questions with answers and references, ready for Sunday school, small group or a Bible quiz night.
1. In what month did the murder of Gedaliah take place?
Answer: In the seventh month. — Jeremiah 41:1
2. Who killed Gedaliah?
Answer: Ishmael son of Nethaniah, with ten men, while they were eating together. — Jeremiah 41:1-2
3. Who arrived at Mizpah the next day, and what did they bring?
Answer: Eighty men from Shechem, Shiloh and Samaria, with offerings and incense for the house of the Lord. — Jeremiah 41:4-5
4. How did ten of those men save their lives?
Answer: They told Ishmael they had hidden stores in the field: wheat, barley, oil and honey. — Jeremiah 41:8
5. Where did Johanan overtake Ishmael?
Answer: By the great pool at Gibeon. — Jeremiah 41:12
6. Why did Johanan's group want to go to Egypt?
Answer: Out of fear of the Chaldeans, because Ishmael had killed the governor appointed by Babylon. — Jeremiah 41:17-18
Application for today
Jeremiah 41 shows how violence and deceit destroy a community's trust and hope. Ishmael feigned mourning in order to kill, and Gedaliah paid for not listening. In a small group you can talk about the importance of truth and about protecting the community from those who take advantage of good faith.
It also warns against deciding out of fear. After the tragedy, Johanan's group thinks of fleeing, and the decision comes not from seeking God but from fearing Babylon. Before making a big decision in a crisis, it is wise to stop, pray and ask what the Lord says, as will happen in the next chapter.
Mizpah was marked with blood, and Johanan's frightened group heads toward Egypt. But before going on, in chapter 42, they ask Jeremiah to pray and seek the word of God.
Frequently asked questions about Jeremiah 41
What was the cistern the text mentions?
A large cistern that King Asa had made in the time of the war against Baasha, king of Israel. Ishmael threw the bodies of the murdered men into it. The detail shows that the text knows the place and its history.