Job · chapter 21 of 42
Updated on
In Job 21 Job answers Zophar with a question that dismantles his friends' doctrine: why do the wicked live, grow old and become mighty? He describes their secure houses, their happy children and their peaceful deaths, though they tell God to depart. He states that one dies in full vigor and another in bitterness, and that his friends' answers are falsehood.
This chapter closes the second cycle and is Job's strongest refutation of the theory of retribution. Until now the friends have maintained that the wicked suffer and the righteous prosper. Job answers from experience: some wicked people live long years and die in peace. The chapter shows that life does not fit a formula, and leaves questions that only God can answer.
Job asks his friends to listen carefully to his words and let that be their consolation. Bear with me, and after I have spoken, mock on. Is my complaint against man? Look at me and be appalled; lay your hand on your mouth. When he remembers, he shudders.
Then he poses his question: why do the wicked live, reach old age and grow mighty in power? Their offspring are established in their presence, and their descendants before their eyes. Their houses are safe from fear, and the rod of God is not upon them. Their bull breeds without fail, their cow calves and does not miscarry. They send out their little boys like a flock, and their children dance. They spend their days in prosperity and go down to Sheol in a moment. Yet they say to God: depart from us, we do not desire the knowledge of your ways. What is the Almighty, that we should serve him? What profit do we get if we pray to him? But their prosperity is not in their own hand, and the counsel of the wicked is far from Job.
How often is the lamp of the wicked put out? The friends say God stores up their punishment for their children, but Job says let him pay it himself, and let his own eyes see his ruin. Who can teach God knowledge? One dies in full vigor, at ease and secure; another dies in bitterness of soul, never having tasted prosperity, and together they lie down in the dust and worms cover them.
Job says he knows his friends' thoughts: they ask where the house of the prince is. Let them ask those who travel the road: the evil man is spared in the day of calamity. Who will declare his way to his face? He is carried to the grave, and watch is kept over his tomb; the clods of the valley are sweet to him. He concludes: how then will you comfort me with empty nothings, when there is nothing left of your answers but falsehood?
References follow ESV book names and verse numbers. Read each verse in your Bible before the explanation.
Job asks why the wicked live, grow old and become mightier. It is the central blow to the doctrine of retribution: if the wicked prosper, Job's suffering does not prove his guilt.
The wicked tell God to depart, that they do not want to know his ways and that it does no good to pray to him. Job shows that this prosperity does not come from devotion, and that there is a prosperity without God.
Job asks who can teach God knowledge, since it is he who judges those on high. He acknowledges that judgment belongs to God, and that neither he nor his friends can fix when and how it is carried out.
Job asks how his friends can comfort him with empty nothings, when nothing is left of their answers but falsehood. It is his verdict on his friends' comfort: a doctrine that does not fit reality does not console but deepens the pain.
6 questions with answers and references, ready for Sunday school, small group or a Bible quiz night.
Answer: To listen carefully to his words and let that be their consolation. — Job 21:2
Answer: Why the wicked live, grow old and become mightier. — Job 21:7
Answer: Secure and happy: their little ones dance and sing to tambourine, lyre and pipe. — Job 21:8-12
Answer: That he should depart from them and that they do not want to know his ways, since they see no point in serving him. — Job 21:14-15
Answer: One in full strength and at ease, another in bitterness, and the two lie down together in the dust. — Job 21:23-26
Answer: As empty nothings, since nothing is left of their answers but falsehood. — Job 21:34
Job 21 is a reminder that life does not always follow a formula. Sometimes the wicked prosper and the righteous suffer, and the Bible says so plainly. The psalms and the prophets acknowledge it, and so the believer should not measure their faith or anyone else's by their well-being. In your group you can talk about why it is dangerous to assume that a prosperous life is a sign of God's favor.
At the same time, the chapter does not conclude that God does not matter. Job keeps arguing with God; he does not abandon him. Final judgment belongs to the Lord, and the New Testament teaches that there will be a day when everything is put in its place. Meanwhile, we trust that God is just even when we do not see it clearly, and we avoid judging other people's lives by what appears.
Job 21 closes the second cycle of speeches without Job having been refuted: the friends fall silent, but they have not persuaded him either. In Job 22 the third cycle will begin with Eliphaz, who will no longer speak in general terms but will accuse Job of specific sins against the poor and needy.
The text gives no explanation: Job simply observes the fact. He uses it as an argument against the friends' doctrine, for whom evil is always punished in this life. Other passages, such as Psalm 73, show the same tension and resolve it by looking to God's final judgment.
It is an objection Job attributes to the friends. If the wicked man does not suffer, they say, his children will pay for him. Job answers that the guilty one himself should pay, and that a justice that punishes others is not justice. It is an argument the Bible develops elsewhere, as in Ezekiel 18.
Because the Bible is honest about the real experiences of life. Job speaks of what he sees and does not hide that his experience challenges simple explanations. In the end God does not rebuke Job for raising these questions, but the friends for defending God with false answers.