Introduction
Judges covers the stretch of Israel's history between the death of Joshua and the rise of the monarchy, roughly three centuries in which the tribes lived in the promised land without a king.
Read one by one, these stories can sound like adventure tales. Read together, they tell a sobering story of decline. The book begins with Israel asking the Lord who should lead the fight against the Canaanites (1:1) and ends with Israelites fighting one another and seizing wives for a nearly destroyed tribe (21:19-23). In between, the same pattern repeats: Israel forgets the Lord, suffers under oppressors, cries out and is rescued, then forgets again.
Judges is honest about human sin, yet above all it is a book about God's patience. The Lord keeps hearing his people's groaning and keeps sending deliverers. Its closing refrain, that there was no king and everyone did what was right in his own eyes (21:25), leaves the reader longing for a faithful king.
Who wrote Judges and when?
The book does not name its author. The Talmud (Bava Batra 14b) attributes Judges to Samuel, and many evangelical scholars consider that possible, at least for the core of the book. The text itself offers several clues:
- The refrain in those days there was no king in Israel (17:6; 18:1; 19:1; 21:25) looks back from a time when Israel did have a king.
- Judges 1:21 says the Jebusites still lived in Jerusalem, which points to a time before David captured the city (2 Samuel 5:6-9).
- Judges 18:30 mentions the day of the captivity of the land. Some see here the Assyrian deportation of the northern tribes in the eighth century BC, and therefore a later editorial note; others link it to the time when the ark was captured and Shiloh lost its role (18:31; 1 Samuel 4).
Taken together, the book probably took shape in the early monarchy, around 1000 BC, perhaps with later updating. Many scholars read Judges as part of a larger history running from Deuteronomy through Kings, shaped to explain Israel's story in light of the covenant.
Dating the period of the judges
Adding up the years of oppression, rest and leadership given in the book yields about 410 years. Yet 1 Kings 6:1 places only 480 years between the exodus and the temple, a span that must also include the wilderness, Joshua, Eli, Samuel, Saul and David. The usual solution is that some judges led different regions at the same time; 10:7 mentions Philistine and Ammonite oppression together, so Jephthah in the east and Samson in the west may overlap. Those who date the exodus c. 1446 BC place the judges c. 1375-1050 BC, and Jephthah's remark that Israel had been in the land 300 years (11:26) fits that view. Those who prefer a later exodus, c. 1260 BC, compress the period into c. 1200-1050 BC.
Literary style and structure
Judges is carefully built in three parts:
- A double introduction (1:1-3:6). The first part reports the military situation: tribe after tribe fails to drive out the Canaanites. The second gives the theological explanation: a generation arose that did not know the Lord, and the cycle of apostasy began (2:10-19).
- The stories of the judges (3:7-16:31), from Othniel to Samson.
- Two appendices (17-21): Micah's idol with the migration of Dan, and the crime at Gibeah with the war against Benjamin.
Repeated formulas
The narrator marks each new cycle with stock phrases. The statement that Israel did what was evil in the sight of the Lord opens new cycles at 3:7, 3:12, 4:1, 6:1, 10:6 and 13:1. The Lord gave or sold them into the hand of an enemy, the people cried out, and the Lord raised up a deliverer. The note that the land had rest closes the stories of Othniel, Ehud, Deborah and Gideon (3:11, 30; 5:31; 8:28), and then it disappears. After Gideon, there is no more rest.
A downward spiral
The judges themselves decline. Othniel is spotless; Ehud is a cunning deliverer; Barak hesitates; Gideon doubts and later makes an idol; Jephthah bargains with God and loses his daughter; Samson breaks every part of his Nazirite calling. At the same time the tribes grow more divided: Gideon calms Ephraim's complaint (8:1-3), Jephthah fights Ephraim (12:1-6), and in the end all Israel goes to war against Benjamin.
Literary art
Judges uses irony (a left-handed deliverer from Benjamin, a name that means son of the right hand), dark humor (fat King Eglon and his servants waiting outside the locked room, 3:24-25), poetry (the Song of Deborah, chapter 5), a fable (Jotham's trees, 9:7-15), a riddle (Samson's, 14:14) and wordplay. The appendices are not in chronological order: Phinehas, Aaron's grandson, is still serving as priest (20:28), and the priest of Dan's shrine is Jonathan, a descendant of Moses (18:30), so these events likely happened early in the period. They are placed at the end because they show where Israel's road was heading.
Judges in the story of the Bible
Judges continues directly from Joshua. Its second introduction (2:6-9) echoes the end of Joshua (Joshua 24:28-31), and Joshua's warning at Shechem, that Israel could not serve the Lord while keeping foreign gods (Joshua 24:19-23), comes true in Judges. The book of Ruth is set in the same era, in the days when the judges ruled (Ruth 1:1). First Samuel then presents the last judges, Eli and Samuel, and Israel's request for a king (1 Samuel 8:5).
Judges also sets the stage for Saul and David. Gibeah, the town of the crime in chapter 19, becomes Saul's hometown (1 Samuel 10:26), and Saul summons Israel to war by cutting oxen in pieces (1 Samuel 11:7), a grim echo of 19:29.
Later Scripture remembers the judges. Samuel recalls Sisera and the deliverers (1 Samuel 12:9-11). Psalm 83:9-11 asks God to act as he did against Sisera, Jabin, Oreb, Zeeb, Zebah and Zalmunna. Isaiah speaks of the day of Midian (Isaiah 9:4; 10:26), and Hosea uses the days of Gibeah as a byword for Israel's corruption (Hosea 9:9; 10:9). In the New Testament, Paul summarizes the period in his sermon at Pisidian Antioch (Acts 13:20), and Hebrews 11:32-34 lists Gideon, Barak, Samson and Jephthah among the heroes of faith.
Judges and Jesus Christ
Judges points to Christ mainly by showing what Israel lacked.
- A deliverer who saves for good. Each judge brings only temporary relief; when the judge dies, the people fall back (2:19). Jesus saves completely and always lives to intercede for his people (Hebrews 7:25).
- A king who does what is right. The refrain about having no king prepares for David, and through David for the Son of David whose kingdom has no end (Isaiah 9:7; Luke 1:32-33). Christ is the righteous King who rules hearts, not only borders.
- The Spirit-empowered Savior. The Spirit of the Lord came upon Othniel, Gideon, Jephthah and Samson (3:10; 6:34; 11:29; 14:6). Isaiah promised a Messiah on whom the Spirit would rest (Isaiah 11:2), and Jesus applied that promise to himself (Luke 4:18).
- Victory through weakness. God reduced Gideon's army so that Israel could not boast (7:2), a pattern Paul sees fulfilled in the cross, where God chose what is weak to shame the strong (1 Corinthians 1:27-29). Isaiah even compares the victory of the promised child to the day of Midian (Isaiah 9:4-6).
- Samson and the greater Deliverer. Samson's birth is announced by an angel to a barren woman, as John the Baptist's would be (Luke 1:13-17), and he is set apart from the womb. Samson defeats the Philistines by his death, but he dies asking for revenge (16:28). Jesus also conquers through his death, yet he prays for his enemies (Luke 23:34). The contrast shows how much greater the true Deliverer is.
Interpretive challenges
Did Jephthah sacrifice his daughter?
Many interpreters read 11:39 literally: Jephthah offered her as a burnt offering, an act the Law condemned (Deuteronomy 12:31; 18:10), and the narrator presents it as a tragedy, not a model. Others note that the mourning centers on her virginity and on the fact that she never knew a man (11:37-39), and conclude she was dedicated to lifelong service at the sanctuary and never married. Either way, the vow was rash, and the story shows how far Canaanite thinking had seeped into Israel.
How can such flawed people be heroes of faith?
Gideon makes an idol, Jephthah sacrifices or loses his daughter, and Samson is ruled by his appetites, yet Hebrews 11:32 names them. Hebrews does not praise their sins; it singles out the moments when they trusted God against impossible odds. Judges shows both sides so that readers admire the faith, avoid the failures and give the glory to God.
What about the violence?
Judges contains assassination, war and the horrifying abuse of chapter 19. The book describes what happened without approving all of it; much of the violence is the fruit of Israel's rejection of God, and the closing refrain is the narrator's verdict. Battles against oppressors are presented as God's acts of deliverance, while the crimes of the appendices appear as signs of a society that has lost its way.
Little-known facts
- Ehud was left-handed (3:15), and he belonged to Benjamin, a name that means son of the right hand. Later the tribe had 700 chosen left-handed men who could sling a stone at a hair and not miss (20:16).
- The English word shibboleth, a password or test of group identity, comes from Judges 12:6, where the men of Ephraim gave themselves away by pronouncing it sibboleth.
- Jotham's story of the trees looking for a king (9:7-15) is one of the very few fables in the Bible; another appears in 2 Kings 14:9.
- In the Hebrew text of 18:30, the name Moses carries a small raised letter n that turns it into Manasseh; ancient rabbinic tradition explains that scribes wanted to spare Moses the shame of a descendant serving an idol.
- Deborah's song in chapter 5 is widely regarded as one of the oldest poems in the Hebrew Bible.
- An Egyptian monument, the Merneptah Stele (c. 1208 BC), mentions a people called Israel in Canaan. It is the oldest known reference to Israel outside the Bible and comes from the era of the judges.
How to study Judges
Reading plan
Judges can be read in three weeks at one chapter a day, or in seven sessions that follow the outline: 1-2, 3-5, 6-9, 10-12, 13-16, 17-18 and 19-21. Read chapters 1 and 2 carefully first, because they give the key to everything else.
What to look for
- Mark every time Israel does evil in the sight of the Lord, every cry for help and every note that the land had rest.
- Note each time the Spirit of the Lord comes upon someone, and what follows.
- Watch the women of the book: Achsah, Deborah, Jael, Jephthah's daughter, Manoah's wife, Delilah and the Levite's concubine. Their stories often reveal the moral health of the men around them.
Teaching it in Sunday school or a small group
Draw the cycle on a board (sin, oppression, cry, deliverer, rest) and let the group place each judge on it, noting the enemy, the years of oppression and the deliverer's strengths and failures. Ask what the Baals of our day are: what people rely on for security and prosperity instead of God. With children and youth groups, Gideon and Samson work well, with emphasis on trusting God and on the cost of disobedience; chapters 19-21 are better handled with adults. End each lesson by pointing to Jesus, the Deliverer who never fails and the King who always does what is right.