Introduction
Malachi closes the Old Testament in Christian Bibles, and it closes it with a conversation. Again and again God makes a statement, the people object with a question and God answers. The result is a book that sounds strikingly modern: a religious community that still goes to the temple, still offers sacrifices and still calls God its Father, but no longer believes that he loves them or cares how they live.
The book's four chapters move from God's opening declaration of love (Malachi 1:2) to the promise of Elijah (4:5-6). Along the way Malachi confronts careless priests, broken marriages, cynicism about justice and withheld tithes, and announces that the Lord himself will come to his temple. Its last words leave the Old Testament looking forward to a messenger who will prepare the way.
Who wrote Malachi and when?
Name or title?
The heading calls the book an oracle of the word of the Lord to Israel by Malachi (1:1). Malachi means my messenger, and God uses the same word in 3:1 when he promises to send his messenger. For this reason some ancient readers understood Malachi as a title: the ancient Greek translation reads 1:1 as by the hand of his messenger, and the Aramaic Targum adds that the messenger was Ezra the scribe. Most interpreters today take Malachi as the personal name of an otherwise unknown prophet, since each of the other books of the Twelve names its prophet in the opening verse.
Dating the book
The book has no date formula, but its details point to the Persian period:
- the temple has been rebuilt and its altar is in use (1:7-10), so it is after 515 BC;
- Judah is ruled by a governor, the same title used for Nehemiah (1:8; Nehemiah 5:14);
- the sins Malachi names match those Nehemiah confronted on his second visit (Nehemiah 13).
Most place Malachi between 460 and 430 BC. Some date him just before Ezra's arrival in 458 BC; others place him around Nehemiah's return after 433 BC. The heading uses the same unusual phrase as Zechariah 9:1 and 12:1, oracle of the word of the Lord, which ties together the end of the Book of the Twelve.
Literary style and structure
A book of disputes
Malachi is built on a pattern of debate, sometimes called disputation:
- God makes a statement (I have loved you, 1:2).
- The people object, usually introduced by the words but you say, with a question such as how have you loved us?
- God replies with evidence and a call to change.
The pattern appears in 1:2, 1:6-7, 2:14, 2:17, 3:7-8 and 3:13, and lets the reader hear the people's own excuses.
God speaks
Most of the book is in God's first person, and the title the Lord of hosts appears more than twenty times in four short chapters, reminding a small province that its God commands the armies of heaven.
Six disputes
- God's love (1:2-5)
- Priests who despise God's name (1:6-2:9)
- Faithlessness in marriage (2:10-16)
- Where is the God of justice? (2:17-3:5)
- Robbing God (3:6-12)
- Is it useless to serve God? (3:13-4:3)
- Closing call: remember Moses, wait for Elijah (4:4-6)
Covenant vocabulary
Malachi speaks of the covenant with Levi (2:4-5, 8), the covenant of the fathers (2:10), the covenant of marriage (2:14) and the messenger of the covenant (3:1). The whole book is a lawsuit about broken covenant faithfulness.
Vivid images
Malachi writes in elevated prose with striking pictures: dung spread on the faces of priests (2:3), the refiner's fire and the launderer's soap (3:2), the windows of heaven (3:10), a day burning like an oven (4:1) and calves leaping from the stall (4:2).
Malachi in the story of the Bible
Malachi belongs with Haggai and Zechariah to the prophets after the exile, and it is best read alongside Nehemiah 13. It looks back to Jacob and Esau (Genesis 25-27), to the covenant of peace with the priestly line of Levi and Phinehas (Numbers 25:11-13; Deuteronomy 33:8-11), to God's design for marriage (Genesis 2:24), to the law given at Horeb (4:4) and to the ministry of Elijah (1 Kings 17 to 2 Kings 2).
In the Hebrew Bible the prophets are followed by the Writings, and the canon ends with Chronicles. In Christian Bibles Malachi stands last, so its promise of a messenger leads directly into the Gospels. Mark opens with Malachi 3:1 combined with Isaiah 40:3 (Mark 1:2-3). Jesus applies Malachi 3:1 to John the Baptist (Matthew 11:10; Luke 7:27), and the angel's announcement to John's father echoes Malachi 4:6 (Luke 1:17). Paul quotes Malachi 1:2-3 in Romans 9:13. At the transfiguration, Moses and Elijah, the two figures named in Malachi's last verses, appear with Jesus (Matthew 17:3).
Malachi and Jesus Christ
- The messenger who prepares the way. John the Baptist prepares the way of the Lord in the wilderness (Matthew 3:1-3), and Jesus identifies him as the messenger of Malachi 3:1 (Matthew 11:10).
- The Lord who comes to his temple. Malachi says the Lord will suddenly come to his temple. Jesus is presented in the temple as an infant (Luke 2:22-38) and later cleanses it, driving out those who turned it into a market (Mark 11:15-17; John 2:13-17).
- The messenger of the covenant. Jesus is the mediator of a better covenant (Hebrews 8:6), sealed in his blood (Luke 22:20).
- The refiner. John the Baptist announced one who would baptize with the Holy Spirit and fire and separate wheat from chaff (Matthew 3:11-12), language close to Malachi 3:2-3 and 4:1.
- The sunrise of righteousness. Zechariah's song at John's birth speaks of the sunrise from on high visiting God's people (Luke 1:78-79), and many hear in it an echo of the sun of righteousness of Malachi 4:2.
- Worship among the nations. Malachi 1:11 foresees God's name honored in every place. Jesus speaks of true worshipers who will worship the Father in spirit and truth, not only in Jerusalem (John 4:21-24).
Interpretive challenges
Did God really hate Esau?
In Hebrew idiom, love and hate can express choosing and not choosing, or preferring one over another. Jacob loved Rachel more than Leah, and the text says Leah was hated (Genesis 29:30-31); Jesus calls his followers to hate their families in comparison with their love for him (Luke 14:26). Malachi speaks of the nations of Israel and Edom and of God's free choice. Paul applies the verse to election (Romans 9:13), and readers differ on how far that election concerns nations and how far it concerns individuals.
What is God's verdict on divorce?
Malachi 2:16 is one of the hardest verses to translate in the book. Whether the verse says that God hates divorce or that the man who hates and divorces his wife does violence, the context is clear: God was the witness of the marriage covenant, and breaking faith with one's wife is treason against both her and God. Jesus later returns to God's design from creation (Matthew 19:3-9).
Is the tithe for Christians?
Malachi speaks to Israel under the law of Moses, whose tithes supported the Levites, the temple and the poor. Some Christians teach the tithe as an abiding principle; others see the New Testament calling for proportionate, cheerful and generous giving without a fixed percentage (2 Corinthians 8-9). Both agree that Malachi exposes the heart that keeps back from God what belongs to him.
Who is the Elijah to come?
Jesus says John the Baptist is the Elijah who was to come (Matthew 11:14; 17:10-13), and Luke explains that John came in the spirit and power of Elijah (Luke 1:17). John himself denied being Elijah in person (John 1:21). Many see the promise fully met in John; others expect a further Elijah-like ministry before the second coming, sometimes connected with the two witnesses of Revelation 11.
Little-known facts
- In Hebrew Bibles Malachi has only three chapters; the four chapters of English and Spanish Bibles come from dividing chapter 3, so 4:1-6 corresponds to 3:19-24.
- The last word of the book in Hebrew refers to a ban of utter destruction. In synagogue reading, and in many printed Hebrew Bibles, the promise of Elijah (4:5) is repeated after the last verse so that the reading does not end on that word.
- Many Jewish families set a cup for Elijah at the Passover meal, an expression of the hope that grew out of Malachi 4:5.
- Herod the Great, king of Judea when Jesus was born, came from an Idumean family, descendants of the Edomites whose land Malachi describes in 1:2-5.
- The priest is also called the messenger of the Lord of hosts (2:7), the same Hebrew word as the prophet's name.
How to study Malachi
Reading plan
Read the whole book in one sitting, about fifteen minutes. Then study it in six sessions following the six disputes, or in four sessions by chapter. Reading Nehemiah 13 first helps you picture the situation.
What to look for
- The people's questions: what excuses do they make, and how does God answer?
- The covenant language and the ways it is broken.
- The contrast between the arrogant and those who fear the Lord (3:13-4:3).
- The promises that look forward to the New Testament (3:1; 4:2, 5-6).
Teaching it in a Sunday school class or small group
The dispute format lends itself to a group: read God's statement aloud, let someone voice the people's objection, then read God's reply. Ask where the same excuses appear today in worship, marriage, money and the suspicion that faithfulness does not pay. Handle tithing and divorce with care, letting the whole Bible speak. End with 4:5-6 and Luke 1:17, showing how the Old Testament's last promise opens the story of Jesus. With youth groups, the book of remembrance in 3:16 is a powerful encouragement to stay faithful when it seems that no one notices.