Introduction
Matthew stands first in the New Testament, and for good reason: it is the bridge between the two testaments. Its opening line ties Jesus to Abraham and David, and its pages are full of quotations from the Law, the Prophets and the Psalms. For much of church history it was the most widely used Gospel, the source of the Beatitudes, the Lord's Prayer and the Great Commission.
Matthew writes like a careful teacher. He arranges his material in blocks, gathers the sayings of Jesus into long discourses and keeps telling his readers how events fulfilled the Scriptures. The result is a Gospel that tells who Jesus is and, at the same time, shows how his disciples should live.
Who wrote Matthew and when?
What tradition says
The Gospel is anonymous, but the title According to Matthew was attached to it very early, and no ancient source names anyone else. Papias, a church leader in Asia Minor in the early second century, quoted by the historian Eusebius, said that Matthew arranged the sayings of the Lord in the Hebrew language. Irenaeus (around AD 180), Origen and Eusebius repeated that Matthew wrote first, for believers of Jewish origin.
What the text suggests
Several details fit a former tax collector. Only this Gospel calls the apostle Matthew the tax collector in the list of the Twelve (Matthew 10:3) and tells his call under the name Matthew (9:9), while Mark and Luke call him Levi. Only Matthew records the episode of the temple tax and the coin in the fish's mouth (17:24-27), and the book shows a lively interest in debts, accounts and coins, from the unforgiving servant (18:23-35) to the talents (25:14-30).
The author knows Jewish customs, the debates of the scribes and the Hebrew Scriptures well, yet writes in clear Greek that does not read like a translation. For that reason many scholars think Papias was speaking of an earlier collection of sayings, not of the Greek Gospel we have.
Dating views
- Before AD 70. Some passages assume the temple is still standing (5:23-24; 17:24-27; 23:16-22), and the ancient church placed Matthew first among the Gospels. Many evangelical scholars date it to the 50s or 60s.
- AD 70-85. Most scholars who hold that Matthew used Mark place it after the fall of Jerusalem, and some read the king who burns the murderers' city (22:7) as an echo of that event.
Matthew, Mark and Luke share so much material that they are called the Synoptic Gospels. Most scholars think Mark was written first and used by Matthew and Luke along with other sources; others, following the ancient order, think Matthew came first. Faithful interpreters hold both views.
Literary style and structure
Five great discourses
Matthew alternates narrative with five long blocks of teaching, each closing with a similar formula:
- The Sermon on the Mount (chapters 5-7), ending at 7:28-29.
- The mission discourse (chapter 10), ending at 11:1.
- The parables of the kingdom (chapter 13), ending at 13:53.
- Life in the community of disciples (chapter 18), ending at 19:1.
- The Olivet discourse on the end of the age (chapters 24-25), ending at 26:1.
Many readers see in these five blocks an echo of the five books of Moses, a fitting pattern for a Gospel that presents Jesus as the one who gives the authoritative meaning of the Law.
Two turning points
Twice Matthew writes that from that time Jesus began to do something: to preach the kingdom (4:17) and to show his disciples that he must suffer in Jerusalem (16:21). These markers divide the book into three movements: who Jesus is (1:1-4:16), his public ministry (4:17-16:20) and his road to the cross and resurrection (16:21-28:20).
Favorite techniques
- Fulfillment formulas. About ten times Matthew notes that something happened to fulfill what the Lord had said through a prophet (for example 1:22-23; 2:15; 4:14-16; 8:17; 21:4-5).
- Groupings. Ten miracles in chapters 8-9, seven parables in chapter 13, seven woes in chapter 23, and a genealogy arranged in three groups of fourteen (1:17).
- Framing. The book begins with Immanuel, God with us (1:23), and ends with Jesus' promise to be with his disciples always (28:20).
- Economy. Matthew often tells miracle stories more briefly than Mark, keeping the focus on the words of Jesus.
Matthew in the story of the Bible
The Old Testament ends with Israel back in the land but still under foreign rule, waiting for the Lord to come to his temple (Malachi 3:1) and for a son of David to reign. Matthew picks up exactly there. His genealogy retells Israel's history in three stages: from Abraham to David, from David to the exile in Babylon, and from the exile to the Messiah.
Jesus then relives Israel's story. Like the nation, he comes out of Egypt (Matthew 2:15), passes through the waters at his baptism and is tested forty days in the wilderness; where Israel failed, he stays faithful, answering the devil each time with words from Deuteronomy (4:1-11). On a mountain he teaches the true meaning of the Law, as Moses once received it at Sinai.
Matthew also leads into the rest of the New Testament. The commission to all nations is carried out in Acts, and the letter of James echoes the Sermon on the Mount, for instance on oaths (James 5:12; Matthew 5:33-37) and on being doers of the word (James 1:22; Matthew 7:24-27).
Matthew and Jesus Christ
Matthew's portrait of Jesus has several layers:
- The King, son of David. The genealogy (1:1-17), the magi's search for the king of the Jews (2:2), the entry on a donkey (21:5-9) and the charge over the cross (27:37) all present Jesus as Israel's rightful King.
- Immanuel, God with us. Jesus is present where two or three gather in his name (18:20) and promises his presence to the end of the age (28:20). He receives worship from the magi (2:11), from the disciples in the boat (14:33) and from the women and the Eleven after the resurrection (28:9, 17).
- The Son of God. The Father declares it at the baptism (3:17) and the Transfiguration (17:5), Peter confesses it (16:16), and a Roman centurion admits it at the cross (27:54).
- The authoritative Teacher. Six times he sets what the people had been told of old beside his own word (5:21-48), and the crowds are amazed because he teaches with authority, not like their scribes (7:28-29).
- The suffering Servant. Matthew applies Isaiah's Servant passages to Jesus (8:17; 12:18-21). Jesus came to give up his life to ransom many (20:28), and at the Last Supper his blood is poured out for the forgiveness of sins (26:28).
- The coming Son of Man. He will come on the clouds and judge the nations (24:30; 25:31-46; 26:64).
Interpretive challenges
Is the Sermon on the Mount an impossible standard?
Some read the sermon mainly as a mirror that exposes sin and drives us to grace; others as the ethic of the future kingdom; others as the way of life for disciples now. The sermon itself starts with blessings rather than demands and includes a prayer for forgiveness (6:12), which suggests it describes the life of people already touched by grace, who grow toward it with the help of God.
What is the rock in Matthew 16:18?
There is a wordplay between the name Peter and the Greek word for rock. Interpreters understand the rock as Peter himself in his role as the leading confessing apostle (compare Ephesians 2:20, where the church is built on the apostles and prophets), as Peter's confession that Jesus is the Christ, or as Christ himself. All these readings agree that the church rests on Jesus, the cornerstone, and on the apostolic witness to him.
Who were the magi, and what was the star?
Matthew says only that they came from the East. The word magi was used for a class of Persian scholars associated with the study of the heavens and dreams. The star has been explained as a miraculous light, a planetary conjunction (Jupiter and Saturn came together several times in 7 BC), a comet or a new star. Matthew simply presents it as God guiding the visitors to the child (2:9-10).
Why does Matthew 27:9 name Jeremiah?
The words about thirty pieces of silver resemble Zechariah 11:12-13, yet Matthew names Jeremiah. A common explanation is that he combines Zechariah with Jeremiah's episodes of the potter and the purchased field (Jeremiah 19; 32:6-15) and cites the better-known prophet, much as Mark 1:2-3 joins Malachi and Isaiah under Isaiah's name.
Little-known facts
- Matthew never says there were three magi; the number was inferred later from the three gifts, and the idea that they were kings is also a later tradition.
- Matthew is the only Gospel that uses the word church, and only twice (16:18; 18:17).
- The genealogy names four women before Mary: Tamar, Rahab, Ruth and the wife of Uriah, something unusual in ancient genealogies.
- The Didache, an early Christian manual usually dated around AD 100, gives the Lord's Prayer in a form very close to Matthew's and tells believers to pray it three times a day.
- Only Matthew tells of Peter walking on the water, Pilate's wife's dream, Pilate washing his hands and the guard posted at the tomb.
How to study Matthew
A reading plan
Reading one chapter a day takes four weeks. For a Sunday school quarter, follow the nine sections of the outline, giving two weeks to the Sermon on the Mount and two to the passion and resurrection.
What to look for
- Mark every fulfillment formula and look up the Old Testament passage it quotes.
- Notice the five discourses and the formula that closes each one.
- Track the titles of Jesus: son of David, Son of God, Son of Man, Immanuel.
- Watch for the words kingdom, righteousness, mountain and worship.
Teaching it in a class or small group
Three questions work well for almost every passage: What does this show about who Jesus is? What does it teach about the kingdom of heaven? What does Jesus ask of his disciples here? For the Sermon on the Mount, let the group pick one Beatitude or one command to practice during the week and share the result at the next meeting. Close the study by memorizing the Lord's Prayer phrase by phrase and the Great Commission (28:18-20), the passage that sends every class back into the world.